Review: Downton Abbey – A Five-Star Historical Drama

Rating: 5 out of 5.

The aristocratic Crawley family and their servants navigate a declining class system’s complexities and tensions

Starring — Hugh Bonneville, Jessica Brown Findlay, Laura Carmichael, Jim Carter, Brendan Coyle, Michelle Dockery, Siobhan Finneran

Production Year — 2010-2015 (original series); 2019, 2022 (films)

The desire to understand the past is universal. People naturally seek to comprehend how we arrived at our current state and why our lives are shaped as they are. Exploring historical films or series provides one of the most effective means to satisfy this curiosity, often surpassing the strict requirements of historical accuracy and reliability in sources. Every now and then, a sprinkle of magic complements the facts. This genre typically portrays historical events and figures, often blending in fictional elements to entertain, educate, and offer unique perspectives on specific time periods.

Compelling Narratives Brought to Life

Downton Abbey stands out for its exceptional quality in many aspects. The series produced by Carnival Films, is a captivating period drama about the Crawley family, aristocrats living at Yorkshire country estate Downton Abbey. Spanning from 1912 to the 1920s, the series follows their lives as they adapt to societal changes and the onset of modernity after the Edwardian era. Mirroring real events like the sinking of the Titanic, the assassination of Archduke Ferdinand and Spanish influenza pandemic, the series illustrates the impact of these events on the characters.

At its core, the series focuses on the personal struggles, ambitions, and relationships of the Crawley family and their servants, revealing romances, tensions, secrets, and dreams. It offers viewers a window into an era of significant societal changes, allowing them to witness life during this transformative period.

Upstairs

The Crawley family represents the complexities of aristocratic life in early 20th-century England, filled with formalities, social duties, and traditions. Managing of the estate, ensuring a financial stability while also managing their own personal affairs and relationships. They attend social events, host dinners, and establish alliances with other aristocratic families.

Led by Robert Crawley (Hugh Bonneville), the Earl of Grantham, and his wife Cora (Elizabeth McGovern), they navigate a changing society. Their three daughters each represent different aspects of their time: Lady Mary (Michelle Dockery) is confident and ambitious, Lady Edith (Laura Carmichael) is resilient, and Lady Sybil (Jessica Brown Findlay) is progressive and idealistic. Violet Crawley, mother of Robert, played by Dame Maggie Smith, holds the matriarchal role of Countess of Grantham with direct, unapologetic manners and sharp-tongued humor. She upholds the house’s legacy and honour with timeless wisdom. Matthew Crawley (Dan Stevens), a distant cousin who unexpectedly becomes the heir to Downton Abbey, disrupting the family’s plans and dynamics. His arrival introduces a fresh perspective, contrasting the traditional aristocratic upbringing with his middle-class sensibilities and modern ideals. Matthew’s mother, Isobel Crawley (Penelope Wilton), a widow and former nurse, challenges aristocratic conventions with her progressive views on social justice and healthcare, highlighting the tensions between traditional and modern ideologies during this transformative era.

Downstairs

Below stairs, dedicated servants ranging from the butler and head cook to footmen and maids, adhere to strict rules and hierarchy while also experiencing moments of friendship, ambition, and occasional tensions.

Key characters include:

Charles “Charlie” Carson (Jim Carter), butler and a strong defender of tradition and protocol. His character evolves through deep relationships and acts of kindness, leaving a lasting legacy of loyalty and integrity at the estate.

Mrs. Patmore (Lesley Nicol), Head Cook balances tradition with modern aspirations in the Downton Abbey kitchen. Her role extends beyond culinary expertise, offering guidance and wisdom to the younger staff members like Daisy while navigating personal and professional challenges.

Anna Smith Bates (Joanne Froggatt), Lady Mary’s loyal and compassionate lady’s maid, provides support and guidance within the household. Her role extends beyond duty.

Tom Branson (Allen Leech) the family chauffeur from a working-class background and holding strong political beliefs, reflecting the changing times.

Daisy Lewis (Sophie McShera), Kitchen Maid starts as a kitchen maid under Mrs. Patmore’s guidance, symbolizing the transition from tradition to modernity towards women’s education and independence.

Thomas Barrow (Rob James-Collier), a Footman from a humble background, is introduced as a manipulative character who struggles with trust and connection, leading to challenges and isolation.

Sarah O’Brien (Siobhan Finneran), Lady Grantham’s Lady’s Maid initially displays loyalty mixed with manipulative tendencies towards characters like Thomas Barrow. Her complex motivations and actions impact the household dynamics, portraying the intricate interplay of power and relationships at Downton Abbey.

What makes Downton Abbey a five star series?

Wrote this post almost two years ago Frankly, my dear, I do give a damn – Jackinna of all Trades and said that (compared to movies) series have more space for characters to grow because of longer runtime and thereby more possibilities to create multidimensional characters, complex stories people truly enjoy when binging. For the same reasons, emotional connections between a character and the audience are being created.

In Downton Abbey, characters evolve significantly across seasons, offering a more realistic portrayal compared to older series where characters tended to remain in static roles. These older shows typically placed less emphasis on character development and adaptation over time.

The evolution of characters in Downton Abbey enables them to face challenges, undergo personal growth, and react to changing circumstances like love and death. This dynamic portrayal captures the complexities of human nature, where characters often face tough decisions to navigate through life. This approach makes the characters more relatable and engaging for modern audiences, as they resonate with the complexities and dilemmas faced by the characters throughout their journeys. The magic of this particular series lies in its ability to change the opinions of characters—no one is ultimately good or bad.

Downton Abbey stands out as one of the most versatile series due to its compelling storytelling and exploration of social class dynamics. Its ability to seamlessly blend drama, romance, and humor ensures it remains highly entertaining and a timeless classic. The depth and authenticity that bring its characters to life are achieved through exceptional acting performances. From the aristocratic Crawley family to the loyal servants, each cast member portrays their role with skill and dedication, capturing the nuances and complexities of their characters’ emotions.

As being one of the most popular series in British television, it gives us a glimpse into a time when honour and duty were very important. This contrasts with today’s world, where social media plays a big role in shaping opinions, trends, and individualism in a diverse global landscape. Reflecting on Downton Abbey in the aftermath of COVID-19 prompts us to consider how societies navigated pandemics then and now, showcasing advancements in healthcare. The show invites comparisons between past and present, encouraging contemplation on the evolution of values and society during times of crisis.



Leave a comment